Skip to Content
Course content

Investing is not only about profits

Elegant Investor in a navy turtleneck with the word ELEGANT, with a laptop on her lap

Investing is not only about profits.

Elegant Informed Investor.

Taxes on Investing Are Rarely Discussed with Beginners.


Materials for people who are just starting to invest explain how to open a brokerage account and how to choose their first stocks. The fact that investing also involves reporting to the tax authorities is usually mentioned in a single sentence. A woman considering her first investment is therefore told that she will eventually have something to report, but not what needs to be reported or when.

The questions left unanswered at that point are very practical. Does a tax become payable as soon as the price of the stocks you own increases. Does a decline in the share price create a loss that can be used for tax purposes. Why does a dividend from a U.S. company reach a brokerage account in an amount lower than the amount announced by the company. Does buying stock in a company from another country mean paying tax twice on the same amount.


Tax Liabilities Arise at Specific Times.


As long as stocks remain in a brokerage account, their gain or loss is unrealized, meaning it exists only as a calculation. In most tax systems, such a result is not subject to tax. A tax liability generally arises when stocks are sold, because that is when the difference between their sale price and purchase price becomes a gain or loss for tax purposes. For the same reason, a decline in the price of stocks you own does not by itself create a loss that can be claimed for tax purposes.

Dividends, meaning a portion of a company's profits paid to shareholders, are subject to a different rule. The tax is generally collected by the country where the company is based, before the money is transferred to the investor. This is known as withholding tax and explains the difference between the dividend amount announced by the company and the amount that ultimately appears in the brokerage account. The same dividend is then subject to tax reporting in the country where the investor files her tax return. To prevent the same income from being effectively taxed twice, countries enter into tax treaties that allow foreign taxes paid to be credited or limit the applicable tax rate.


Where the Name Elegant Informed Investor Came From.


The name refers to two types of knowledge that come together in this lesson. The first concerns taxes, meaning recognizing events that create a tax liability and those that do not. The second concerns the information on which an investor bases her decisions.

More stock-market content is published today than anyone could possibly read, and its authors compete for readers' attention. Some of it is educational, while some is created to generate clicks and provoke a strong emotional response. The difference can often be recognized from the structure of the headline and from what is missing from the text, such as a data source or information about risk. The meaning of the word recommendation also matters. Under applicable regulations, an investment recommendation means a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold a specific financial instrument, and such recommendations may be issued only by persons and institutions subject to regulatory oversight and professional liability. A social media post naming a company and promising quick profits usually comes from someone who does not meet any of these requirements.


What the Fourth Lesson Covers.


We begin with the three areas of taxation that an Elegant Investor is most likely to encounter, meaning fees charged in connection with a transaction, dividend tax, and capital gains tax, explaining when each one arises. We then discuss the difference between an unrealized result and the sale of stocks, as well as the rules for reporting losses. The next part focuses on investing in foreign companies. We explain how withholding tax works, how tax treatment is determined both in the country where the company is based and in the country where the investor files her taxes, and the mechanisms provided under tax treaties. We also discuss the forms in which companies distribute dividends, how the source of income affects its taxation, wealth taxes that apply in some countries, and how investments held in foreign currencies are reported. A separate section covers accounts that receive preferential tax treatment in some countries. The lesson concludes with information hygiene, meaning distinguishing educational content from manipulative content, recognizing the characteristics of click-driven headlines, and understanding the requirements that regulations impose on investment recommendations.

The fourth lesson of Elegant Investor Start addresses when investing creates a tax liability and how the credibility of market information can be assessed.



A woman resting her cheek on her hand, in a turtleneck with the word ELEGANT, at a laptop

Elegant Investor
Start

1 399 EUR

A smiling woman in a cream blouse with a mug in front of her bearing the words ELEGANT INVESTORS

Elegant Investors
Coffee Time

Book a free online meeting.

Go to the calendar

A woman in glasses and a cream sweater typing on a laptop held on her lap

Contact
Elegant Investors

​Ask a question about this course.

Open the contact form

HM Revenue and Customs (rules for taxing investment income in the United Kingdom and the list of double taxation agreements, gov.uk), U.S. Internal Revenue Service (withholding tax on dividends paid to non-residents and the rules of retirement accounts, irs.gov), Polish Ministry of Finance (the rate of capital income tax quoted in the lesson for Poland, gov.pl), Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (the model tax convention on which double taxation agreements are based, oecd.org), European Securities and Markets Authority (the market abuse regulation and the rules for preparing investment recommendations, esma.europa.eu), Financial Conduct Authority (requirements for investment recommendations and protection of individual investors, fca.org.uk).

Rating
0 0

There are no comments for now.

to be the first to leave a comment.