The moment when theory becomes action

Placing your first order to buy or sell shares can be the moment when theory stops being enough. Until now, you can read about the market, companies and a brokerage account, but at the order form, very concrete questions appear. At what price can the transaction be concluded, why it sometimes happens at once, and sometimes the order remains unexecuted, and what the settings visible in the brokerage system actually mean. It is precisely at this stage that many beginner Elegant Investors start to look for a simple explanation of how buying and selling shares looks in practice.

Understanding the order-placement mechanism is also important when you are interested in long-term investing. It is worth knowing how a limit order differs from a market order, what partial execution means and why the price of the last transaction visible in the quotes will not always be the price at which you buy or sell shares. Such knowledge helps you better read the situations that appear on a brokerage account and move more freely on the practical side of investing.

What an order to buy and sell shares involves

An order is simply an instruction that you pass through your brokerage account. In it, you state that you want to buy or sell a set number of shares of a given company. At the same time, you indicate the conditions on which such a transaction is to take place. This is very important because clicking buy or sell does not yet automatically mean that a transaction is concluded on any terms. 

The market works by set rules, and your order has to be matched to an order from the other side. If you want to buy shares, there must be someone on the other side who wants to sell them. If you want to sell, someone has to appear who wants to buy. The stock exchange does not sell shares on its own. It is a place where investors' orders meet. When the buyer's and seller's conditions agree, a transaction takes place.

This explains why the mere presence of a price next to a company's name does not yet give full information. The price shown in the quotes often reflects the price of the most recent concluded transaction. It does not mean, however, that you will buy shares at exactly this price at the same moment. Everything depends on what buy and sell offers are currently available on the market.

What you will see when placing an order

When you enter the order form on a brokerage account, you usually see a few basic fields. Most often, you have to choose the type of operation (buying or selling), enter the number of shares, specify the type of order, set the price if the type requires it, and indicate the order's validity period. At first glance this looks rather technical, but each of these fields has a simple meaning.

The number of shares simply means how many units you want to buy or sell.

The price indicates the maximum price you want to buy at or the minimum price you want to sell at, if you use a limit order.

The validity period determines how long the order must wait before execution. Sometimes it will be only the current trading session, and sometimes a few days that follow, depending on the settings available with the broker.

Already at this stage you can see that placing an order is not only about confirming the wish to buy. It is the moment when you set the conditions of the transaction. The better you understand these fields, the easier it is to use a brokerage account with more freedom and fewer unnecessary mistakes.

A limit order and a market order

The two basic types of orders worth knowing from the start are the limit order and the market order. Their difference is very important because it affects both the price and the likelihood that the order will be carried out.

A limit order lets you set a boundary you do not want to cross. With a purchase, it means the highest price you are willing to accept. With a sale, it is the lowest price you agree to. If you want to buy shares with a limit of 50, your order can be executed at or below 50. If the cheapest sell offer is 51, the transaction will not take place, because the price exceeds the limit you set.

This solution gives more control over the price. For this reason, it is more transparent for many beginners. You know under what conditions you want to conclude the transaction, and you do not fully hand the decision over to the market. You have to remember, however, that control over the price does not guarantee execution. If the market does not reach the indicated level, the order will simply stay unexecuted.

A market order works differently. It means agreeing to conclude the transaction at the best available price present on the market at a given moment. With a purchase, the system looks for the most favourable current sell offer, and with a sale, the most favourable current buy offer. This type of order usually increases the likelihood of faster execution but also gives less control over the price. If the market is very liquid, the differences can be small. If, however, there are few offers or the situation changes dynamically, the execution price may turn out different from what you assumed.

What liquidity means and why it matters

Liquidity means how easily you can buy or sell the shares of a given company without a major effect on their price. If a company is large and popular, and many transactions are concluded every day, we usually speak of higher liquidity. If interest is smaller and few buy and sell orders appear, liquidity is lower.

In practice, with high liquidity, it is easier to conclude a transaction more quickly at a price close to the one quoted by the company. With low liquidity, the differences between the available buy and sell offers can be larger. It can then happen that a purchase at a set price does not take place, or that a market order is carried out at a price less favourable than you assumed. The most important thing here is to understand that placing the order itself proceeds similarly regardless of the chosen company, but the conditions of its execution can differ clearly. It looks different for a company whose shares are traded very often, and different when the number of transactions and available offers is clearly smaller.

What the execution of an order looks like in practice

The easiest way to understand this topic is through a simple example. Let us assume you want to buy 10 shares of a company. At a given moment, there are sell offers on the market for 4 shares at 100, 3 shares at 100.20 and 10 shares at 100.50. If you set a buy order with a limit of 100, your order can be executed only at or below 100. This means the transaction will not be concluded at 100.20 or at 100.50. Depending on the execution rules in force at the broker and the offers available on the market, the order may be executed in full or in part, or remain pending.

If, however, you choose a market order, you agree to buy at the best available prices present on the market at a given moment. In such a case, the system may first buy 4 shares at 100, then 3 shares at 100.20, and then another 3 shares at 100.50. The whole order will then be carried out, but not at one price. This shows that a single transaction can be settled in several parts at different price levels.

On this basis, it is easier to understand what partial execution of an order is. It means that only part of the order has been carried out, and the rest is still awaiting the possibility of concluding a transaction on terms consistent with the instruction. If you see a message about partial execution on your account, it does not mean an error. It means that only part of the order was matched to the available offers on the market at a given moment.

The validity period of an order and its status after sending

When placing an order, you usually also have to indicate its validity period. This is information about how long the order is to remain active. The simplest option means validity only until the end of the current session. If the order is not carried out that day, it expires. Another possibility is to set a validity period until a specific date, so the order can wait longer.

This setting has practical meaning. If you care about buying only today, you will choose a shorter validity period. If a set price still suits you for the following days as well, you can leave the order active longer. It is worth remembering, however, that the market situation can change, and an order set a few days earlier should still match your assumptions.

After sending the order, you may see various statuses. The order may be accepted for execution, carried out in full, carried out partially, or unexecuted. For a beginner Elegant Investor, it is important not to treat the click itself as the end of the process. Only the order status shows what actually happened on the market.

Buying and selling work by the same rules

Although many beginner Elegant Investors focus mainly on buying shares, it is worth knowing right away that selling works by exactly the same rules. With a sale, you also choose the number of shares, the type of order, the price, and the validity period. Here, too, partial execution can occur, or the order may not be carried out if no one wants to buy the shares under the conditions you indicated.

This matters especially in long-term investing because a sale should not be a nervous reaction to a single price move. It is good to understand the technical side of selling before the need to use it appears. Thanks to this, it is easier to maintain consistency between your decision and how it is implemented in the market.

What to check before confirming an order

Before finally confirming the order, it is worth taking a moment to review a few elements.

1. Make sure you have chosen the right company and the right listing market.
2. Check the number of shares and the total transaction value.
3. See what type of order you chose and whether the set price matches what you want to achieve.
4. Also check the order's validity period and remember the brokerage commission, as it affects the final purchase cost or the value of the funds received after the sale.

It is also good practice to look at what the brokerage system shows just before sending the order. If you see a spread between buy and sell offers, it is easier to understand the current market conditions. This does not require advanced analysis. Attentiveness is enough, along with the awareness that each piece of information affects the transaction's technical outcome.

The most important conclusions

An order to buy or sell shares is a basic element of investing in the stock market. The decision to choose a company alone is not enough, because the conditions on which the transaction is to be concluded are equally important. The price, the type of order, the number of shares and the validity period of the instruction all matter. The better you understand these elements, the easier it is to read what happens after placing an order and what its way of execution results from.

Especially important are the distinctions between a limit order and a market order, as well as an understanding of market liquidity. It is also worth noting that an order can be executed in full, partially, or remain unexecuted. Such knowledge helps you better understand the practical side of investing and more accurately interpret the situations that appear on a brokerage account.

Sources:

Investopedia (definitions of limit orders, market orders and liquidity, https://www.investopedia.com), Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (investor education on order types and execution, https://www.investor.gov), Fidelity (educational materials on placing stock orders, https://www.fidelity.com), Charles Schwab (educational resources on order types and trade execution, https://www.schwab.com), Nasdaq (information on market liquidity and quotes, https://www.nasdaq.com), CFA Institute (investor education on market mechanics, https://www.cfainstitute.org), ESMA, the European Securities and Markets Authority (guidance on order execution for retail investors, https://www.esma.europa.eu).

Take the quiz